Comparing Single-Family and Multifamily Homes for Real Estate Investing Success

Comparing Single-Family and Multifamily Homes for Real Estate Investing Success

Table of Contents

Investing in real estate can be a great way to build wealth, but choosing the right type of property is key to your success. Two popular options are single-family homes and multifamily homes.

Each comes with its own set of benefits and challenges. Understanding these differences can help you decide which type of property aligns best with your investment goals.

In this article, we’ll break down the basics of single-family and multifamily homes. We’ll look at the pros and cons of each, compare them side by side, and explore their potential returns on investment (ROI) for real estate investors.

Whether you’re a new investor or looking to expand your portfolio, this guide will help you make an informed decision.

Let’s get started!

What Is Single Family Investing?

Single-family investing means buying houses designed for one family to live in. These are standalone homes, often with their own yards and no shared walls with neighbors. Investing in single-family homes involves buying these properties, renting them out to tenants, and making money from the rent they pay.

Key Features of Single-Family Homes

  • Standalone Property: Single-family homes are separate buildings. Single-family properties are not attached to other homes, giving tenants more privacy.
  • One Unit: These homes are designed to house one family or group of people, unlike multifamily properties which have multiple units.
  • Yard and Space: They often come with a yard or outdoor space, which can be attractive to tenants, especially families.

Common Uses for Single-Family Homes in Investing

  • Rental Income: The primary use is renting out the home to tenants. The rent collected can provide a steady income stream.
  • Fix and Flip: Some investors buy single-family homes that need repairs, fix them up, and then sell them for a profit.
  • Vacation Rentals: In popular tourist areas, single-family homes can be rented out short-term to vacationers through platforms like Airbnb.

Understanding single-family investing is the first step in deciding if this type of real estate investment is right for you. It offers simplicity and high demand but comes with its own set of risks and responsibilities.

What Is Multifamily Investing?

Multifamily investing involves buying properties that have multiple separate living units within one building or complex. Examples include duplexes, triplexes, apartment buildings, and condominiums. Investing in multifamily homes means renting out these units to multiple tenants, which can provide multiple streams of income from one property.

Key Features of Multifamily Homes

  • Multiple Units: Multifamily properties have more than one living unit, allowing you to rent to several tenants.
  • Shared Walls: These units usually share walls, floors, or ceilings with each other.
  • Common Areas: There may be shared spaces like hallways, laundry rooms, or parking areas.

Common Uses for Multifamily Homes in Investing

  • Rental IncomeThe main use is renting out each unit to different tenants, creating multiple income streams from one multifamily building.
  • Commercial Leasing: In some cases, multifamily properties may include commercial units on the ground floor, adding another income source.
  • Affordable Housing: Multifamily properties can be used to provide affordable housing options, potentially qualifying for government incentives.

While it offers the potential for higher cash flow and lower vacancy risk, it also involves greater complexity and higher initial costs

Advantages and Disadvantages

When deciding between single-family and multifamily homes for your real estate investment, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each.

Both types of properties have their own unique benefits and challenges. Understanding these can help you make a more informed decision that aligns with your investment goals.

Single Family Homes

Single-family homes are standalone properties designed for one family, whereas multifamily buildings cater to multiple tenants. One of the main advantages of investing in single-family homes is that they are usually easier to manage.

With only one tenant to deal with, there are fewer issues to handle compared to multifamily properties. This makes single-family homes a good option for new investors or those who prefer a simpler investment.

Another benefit is that single-family homes are in high demand. Many people prefer to live in a house with its own yard and no shared walls, which is often the case with single-family properties.

This high demand can make it easier to find and keep tenants. Additionally, single-family homes tend to appreciate in value over time, which means you could make a good profit if you decide to sell.

However, there are also disadvantages. If your single-family home becomes vacant, you lose all your rental income until you find a new tenant.

You are also responsible for all the maintenance and repairs, which can be expensive and time-consuming.

Lastly, building a large portfolio of single-family homes can take a lot of time and effort since you have to buy each property individually.

Multi Family Homes

Multifamily homes are properties that have multiple separate living units. This can include duplexes, triplexes, apartment buildings, and condos.

One of the biggest advantages of multifamily investing is the multiple streams of income. Even if one unit is vacant, the other units can still provide rental income, which reduces the risk of losing all your income at once.

Managing multifamily homes can also be more efficient. Since all the units are in one location, it can be easier and cheaper to handle maintenance and repairs.

Multifamily properties often generate higher overall rental income compared to single-family homes, which can lead to better cash flow.

Additionally, lenders may offer better financing options for multifamily properties because they are considered less risky due to the multiple income streams.

On the downside, multifamily properties usually cost more upfront, which often requires a larger mortgage. They also require more complex management, especially if you have many tenants.

This often means hiring a property management company, which can eat into your profits. Maintenance costs can also be higher because there are more units and common areas to take care of.

Also, dealing with multiple tenants means higher chances of turnover and vacancies, which can be challenging to manage.

So, if you understand the advantages and disadvantages of single-family and multifamily homes, you can better decide which type of property suits your investment strategy and financial goals.

Comparing Single-family vs Multifamily Rentals

If you’re comparing single-family and multi-family rentals then it’s not that hard to decide. The important part is to compare key factors to determine which is the best fit for your investment goals. Here are some points to consider:

Single-family Rentals

  • Management Simplicity: Easier to manage with only one tenant.
  • Tenant Demand: High demand from families and individuals wanting privacy and a yard.
  • Vacancy Risk: If the property is vacant, you lose all rental income.
  • Maintenance: Only one unit to maintain, but you are responsible for all repairs.
  • Appreciation: Typically, single-family homes appreciate well over time.
  • Financing: Easier to secure financing for a single-family home.
  • Tenant Turnover: Generally lower turnover rates compared to multifamily properties.

Multi-family Rentals

  • Income Streams: Multiple units provide multiple income streams, reducing risk.
  • Management Complexity: More complex to manage with several tenants; may need a property manager.
  • Tenant Demand: High demand in urban areas or places with many renters.
  • Vacancy Risk: Less risk if one unit is vacant, as other units still generate income.
  • Maintenance: More units mean higher maintenance and repair needs.
  • Cash Flow: Often generates higher overall rental income and better cash flow.
  • Financing: Can be harder to finance due to higher purchase prices, but lenders may view it as less risky due to multiple income streams.
  • Tenant Turnover: Higher turnover rates, require more effort to keep units occupied.

As you see, comparing these factors, you can decide whether single-family or multifamily rentals align better with your investment strategy and goals.

Each type of property offers unique benefits and challenges, so it’s important to choose the one that fits your needs.

Return on Investment (ROI) 

Return on Investment (ROI) is a key factor to consider when deciding between single-family and multifamily rentals. ROI measures the profitability of an investment and helps you understand how much money you can make.

Let’s compare the ROI of single-family and multifamily rentals with specific examples.

ROI for Single-family vs. Multifamily Rentals

Here’s a table that illustrates the potential ROI for a single-family home and a multifamily property:

AspectSingle-family HomeMultifamily Property
Purchase Price$250,000$750,000
Down Payment (20%)$50,000$150,000
Monthly Rent Income$1,800$6,000 (4 units @ $1,500 each)
Annual Rent Income$21,600$72,000
Property Management Fees$2,160 (10% of rent)$7,200 (10% of rent)
Annual Maintenance Costs$1,500$4,500
Annual Property Taxes$2,500$7,500
Annual Insurance$1,000$3,000
Total Annual Expenses$7,160$22,200
Net Annual Income$14,440$49,800
ROI Calculation(Net Income / Down Payment) * 100(Net Income / Down Payment) * 100
ROI(14,440 / 50,000) * 100 = 28.88%(49,800 / 150,000) * 100 = 33.20%

Single-family Home: With a purchase price of $250,000 and an annual rental income of $21,600, the single-family home generates a net annual income of $14,440 after expenses. This results in an ROI of 28.88% for the real estate investor.

Multifamily Property: With a purchase price of $750,000 and an annual rental income of $72,000, the multifamily property generates a net annual income of $49,800 after expenses. This results in an ROI of 33.20%.

Of course, this is just an example, you can always look for the market and find better deals and we advise you to read this article to learn how to do it;

Also Read; How to Find Out If a Property Is Good for Flip or Rental


Choosing between single-family and multifamily homes for real estate investing can be tough, but knowing the differences can help.

Single-family homes are easier to manage and have high tenant demand, but you risk losing all income if the property is vacant. Multifamily homes offer more income streams and better cash flow but need more complex management and cost more upfront.

Looking at the return on investment (ROI), multifamily homes often provide higher returns because of their multiple rental units. However, the right choice depends on your investment goals, risk tolerance, and resources.

If you’re ready to invest in rental properties and need financing, consider Amplend’s rental loan services. Amplend offers loan solutions to help you achieve your real estate investment goals. Whether you choose single-family or multifamily properties, Amplend’s rental loans provide the financial support you need.

Start your real estate investment journey today with the right property and reliable financing from Amplend.

We provide flexible, tailored financing solutions for you.

We believe that by staying true to our values, we can help our clients achieve their financial goals and make a positive impact on real estate communities throughout the nation.